FEBRUARY 3, 2023 – As I review appraisal reports, I continue to see appraisers remain in the fantasy AppraisalLand regarding cap rates and values. When asked about declining values and increasing cap rates, I get the NIMBY reply. No decline in our market. Must be occurring everywhere else:)
Although the GreenStreet CPPI is for investment-grade properties, it is still an indicator of the overall CRE market.
file:///C:/Users/Owner/Desktop/2023%202%20Feb%202%20-%20GreenStreet%20CPPI%20update.pdf
Overall prices have declined back to pre-pandemic levels. Have you been adjusting 2021 and 2022 sale prices downward at least 10%-20%? Have you been using cap rates 75-100bp higher than those shown in 2021 and 2022 sales? Are you forecasting residential lot and home price declines of 10%-20%+ (should be WAY more for finished lots) over the next 1-2 years? Have you adjusted absorption rates in 2022 downward 50%-75%+?
As me and my wife have joked for decades, in AppraisalLand every subdivision sells out quickly….office buildings in markets that literally haven’t seen vacancy rates below 10% since the 1980’s will lease up to 95%…on and on. Vacant land that has been for sale for 30 years will have a marketing time of 12 months. AppraisalLand is a very, very happy place to be in lol
It is up to reviewers to start pushing back hard on conclusions that don’t reflect current and future market conditions. Market Value is based on looking forward thru the windshield, not looking in the rear-view mirror. Data from the rear-view mirror must be adjusted to reflect current and future market conditions.
The above has been a broken record for my entire 36-year career. You would think the industry would learn from past cycles and change quickly when the market changes. It is not acceptable to wait until sales data is available to show the decline has occurred. Sales volume dries up in a declining market. By the time you have sales data the bottom has probably occurred and the market is starting to turn up. Reports like this one from GreenStreet provide the data needed to reflect current and upcoming market conditions. The data proving a decline has occurred and may continue is readily available. Use it.
I have a dream that one day AppraisalLand will no longer exist.
Shalom,
The Mann
Tag Archives: appraisers
FANNIE MAE STUDY CONCLUDES NO RACIAL BIAS IN APPRAISALS
MARCH 12, 2002 – Now, two studies of millions of appraisals by the American Enterprise Institute (AEI) and Fannie Mae have concluded that there is no racial bias in real estate appraisals.
For those involved in the industry, this comes as no surprise. It is essentially impossible for real estate appraisers to be biased. Probably 95% of the time the appraiser knows nothing about the physical characteristics of the borrower. Nearly 100% of the time the appraisal reviewers know nothing about the borrower. And ALL appraisals must be approved by a reviewer.
Also, the market sets prices and all appraisers do is analyze recent comparable sales and arrive at a value for the subject. Which, in purchase situations, is equal to or higher than the sales price 95%+ of the time.
Racist organizations like the Brookings Institution and others that are falsely complaining about appraisal bias need to ‘follow the science’ as they like to say. Scientific studies 100% conclusively say there is no appraisal bias.
Maxine Waters and President Biden owe the appraisal industry an apology. And so does the Appraisal Institute for not supporting its own members.
The real estate appraisal industry is the gold standard for an unbiased profession. We have been the independent referee for 80+ years.
Lastly, we all know about the Fair Housing Act, redlining, discrimination being illegal, et al. To say we need to be educated about such is ridiculous. If you have lived in America since the 1970’s, you know all about fair housing laws and what is and is not discrimination.
The true racists are those that accuse everyone else of being racist. These people need to be exposed and told where to stick their unfounded claims. They should be sued for slander and defamation, also.
Hey, Appraisal institute, get a backbone and stand up for your members! There is no legislation that can change 4,000+ years of economic theory. The appraisal industry does not need to make any changes. It is already fully diverse and inclusive of people of all socio-economic classes (I grew up in mobile homes and am Jewish….I have the low-priced housing and minority characteristics covered!). Remember, skin-color and the only two genders have nothing to do with diversity and inclusivity.
Shalom,
The Mann
STUDY CONCLUDES THAT APPRAISERS ARE NOT BIASED
JANUARY 8, 2021 – The American Enterprise Institute has published a study about the possibility that appraisers have intentional or even unintentional racial bias. Their conclusion is:
We conclude allegation that knowing the race of the applicant results in racial bias by appraisers on refinance loans is uncommon and not systemic. This same analysis supports the conclusion that unintentional bias based on race is also uncommon and not systemic.
You can find the article and link to the report at:
It would be nice if the racially biased Brookings Institute would issue an apology to the appraisal industry. But, racists have an agenda and do not apologize. Thankfully, there is access to actual data and entities like the AEI can analyze and report the facts.
Basically, it is simply impossible for the appraisal industry to be racial or gender biased. Probably 99%+ of the time appraisers know nothing about the physical characteristics about the borrower in residential transactions. Also, every appraisal report is reviewed and I would say near 100% of the time the reviewers know nothing about the borrower at all.
AVMs are often used in the residential arena and they know nothing about the borrower nor the subject’s neighborhood, et al. To them, data is data. Finding the best comparables is based on analyzing numbers. That simple. And for the most part, it is the same for human appraisers.
There is one group of people in real estate that can have significant bias. I won’t name them. You can probably figure it out. There might actually be a few groups involved in this arena that can have bias. That is not to say it is widespread and rampant.
For those who want to keep the ‘conversation’ going, provide the AEI report. You will see how fast the other side wants to stop the conversation and change the subject:)
Great work AEI. I hope they will now do a study about the 20 million whites that live in poverty and see what it is about their neighborhoods that is common and how action can be taken to improve their standard of living….and housing. At the same time, I am sure those solutions can help everyone that lives in poverty. Remember, poverty is colorblind.
The Mann
SHARING A GREAT POST ABOUT APPRAISERS AND CORONAVIRUS
MARCH 16TH – Here is a link to a great post by VaCAP. This should benefit both appraisers and lenders. Be safe out there folks!